Thrifting Into Fall: Affordable Fashion, Endless Possibilities

Fall in New York and New Jersey is one of the best times to refresh your wardrobe — the air cools, the layers return, and style takes center stage. But updating your closet doesn’t have to mean spending a fortune.

Thrifting at Goodwill NYNJ lets you shop this season’s trends sustainably and affordably, while supporting job programs that make a difference in local communities. Whether you’re after cozy sweaters, chic outerwear, or unique accessories, you’ll find something to love on every rack.

Here’s your guide to the top fall thrift trends to look for at Goodwill NYNJ this season.

1. Oversized Knits and Cozy Layers

Fall fashion starts with comfort, and nothing says comfort like an oversized sweater. Chunky knits, cardigans, and turtlenecks are easy to find at Goodwill NYNJ — often in premium materials like wool or cashmere for a fraction of retail price.

Pair an oversized sweater with vintage jeans or a midi skirt for an effortlessly relaxed look. Thrifted sweaters also make great DIY projects! Try cropping, distressing, or embellishing them to create something uniquely yours.

Tip: Check both men’s and women’s sections. Some of the best oversized pieces hide in unexpected places.

2. Vintage Denim That Never Goes Out of Style

Denim is timeless, but fall is when it really shines. Look for high-waisted jeans, denim jackets, and structured skirts that blend classic silhouettes with vintage flair.

At Goodwill NYNJ, you’ll often find iconic brands like Levi’s, Wrangler, and Gap — plus one-of-a-kind retro styles from decades past. Pairing denim with thrifted blazers or boots creates a balanced fall outfit that’s both practical and fashion-forward.

Pro Tip: Try a Canadian tuxedo (denim on denim) — it’s making a big comeback.

3. Statement Outerwear for Every Occasion

Outerwear is the centerpiece of fall dressing. From trench coats and leather jackets to wool blazers and pea coats, the outer layer defines your entire look.

Thrifting coats at Goodwill NYNJ lets you explore different textures, lengths, and styles without overspending. Many shoppers report finding name-brand and vintage pieces in excellent condition — the kind of statement coats that can last for years.

If you’re feeling creative, you can also upcycle a thrifted coat with new buttons, patches, or lining to make it completely unique.

4. Earth Tones and Textured Fabrics

This fall, fashion is all about warm neutrals and tactile materials. Think camel, rust, olive, and deep burgundy, all shades that complement the changing leaves.

Corduroy, suede, wool, and flannel are easy to find secondhand, and they instantly give your outfits that cozy fall aesthetic. Thrift stores are perfect for experimenting with these textures without committing to high retail prices.

At Goodwill NYNJ, you’ll often find entire racks of color-coordinated clothing, making it easy to build cohesive, seasonal looks.

5. Accessories That Elevate Any Look

Fall accessories are the secret to turning simple thrift finds into standout outfits. Look for:

• Leather belts to define oversized silhouettes
• Scarves and hats in plaid or wool textures
• Vintage handbags for a classic touch
• Boots and loafers that mix comfort with polish

Goodwill NYNJ’s accessory sections often hold hidden gems — from designer bags to perfectly broken-in leather shoes. Adding just one or two thrifted accessories can transform a basic look into a fall-ready outfit.

6. Sustainable Shopping Meets Seasonal Style

Thrifting is more than a trend; it’s a movement toward conscious, sustainable living. Shopping at Goodwill NYNJ reduces textile waste, supports local employment programs, and helps keep thousands of pounds of clothing out of landfills each year.

Choosing secondhand fashion is an easy way to refresh your wardrobe guilt-free. Each piece has a story — and by reimagining it, you’re part of a larger story about community, sustainability, and purpose.

Fall fashion feels even better when it makes a positive impact.

7. Home Décor for Cozy Fall Vibes

Goodwill NYNJ isn’t just for clothing. The home section is filled with affordable décor pieces that bring warmth and personality to your space.

Look for:

• Ceramic mugs for your fall coffee moments
• Candlesticks, vases, and frames in seasonal tones
• Blankets and textiles for layering cozy textures
• Thrifting décor helps you create an inviting home without overspending, and gives pre-loved items a meaningful second life.

Why Thrifting at Goodwill NYNJ Is Always in Style

Beyond great prices and unique finds, shopping at Goodwill NYNJ directly supports a mission that empowers individuals across New York and New Jersey through job training, employment services, and community programs.

Every sweater, jacket, or pair of jeans you buy contributes to that mission. It’s an opportunity to look good, feel good, and do good — all in one trip.

When you thrift with Goodwill, you’re not just following fashion trends — you’re helping set a new standard for sustainable, community-driven shopping.

Visit Goodwill NYNJ and Find Your Fall Style

Fall fashion doesn’t have to come from fast fashion racks. It can come from the heart of your community. Visit your local Goodwill NYNJ store to discover this season’s best thrift finds, refresh your wardrobe sustainably, and support programs that change lives.

New arrivals hit the racks daily — so every visit offers something new. Find your fall favorites, save money, and make a difference with every purchase.

Explore more about Goodwill’s mission and store locations at GoodwillNYNJ.org.